St Andrews club secretary Brett Wells is hoping his side can "prove people wrong" against 2012 finalists West Auckland Town during their Semi-Final in The FA Vase.
The Leicestershire club defeated Newcastle Benfield 1-0 in their quarter final and have been drawn against the only club of the quartet to play at Wembley before.
But St Andrews, who have never made it to this stage of the competition before, are raring to go against their County Durham opponents.
West Aukland Town v St. Andrews
The FA Carlsberg Vase
Semi-Final first leg
3pm, Saturday 29 March
Darlington Road, West Auckland Town FC
Winners receive £6000
By Haydn Cobb
Wells, whose uncle and father helped found the club, said: "It'll be such a big occasion for the whole club and we've been underestimated before and proven people wrong, so we are looking to do it again.
"Newcastle Benfield were favourites in our quarter final and we had to give a dogged performance to come away with victory."
West Auckland Town gained revenge on Dunston in their Sixth Round tie with a 1-0 victory and after painfully losing The FA Vase Final two years ago, they are now favourites to lift the trophy this year.
But St Andrews are challenging towards the top in their division - and have games in hand - so Wells wouldn't rule out the chance of his club becoming champions.
The challenge for them is managing their packed fixture list before the first leg of the Semi-Final on Saturday.
St Andrews have to fulfil their games in hand on teams above them in the league and play a county cup semi-final against Graham Street Prims on Thursday.
Wells added: "We have done as much as we can to get ready for West Auckland, but with a league game on Tuesday and a county cup semi final on Thursday, it's going to be tough.
"But our own success has brought this situation on us."
Wells also explained how the club have spread responsibility between the first team and reserves to maintain their challenge on a possible treble.
"This being our first time in The FA Vase Semi-Final gives a fantastic team spirit," he added.
"The financial boost has been split between the players and we've had massive support from the fans and the local media."